Two plumbers can quote the same water heater and still be offering different jobs. One includes the permit and removal of the old tank. Another leaves those costs out. Before deciding which price makes sense, check what you're getting for it.

Look for the brand, model and size. “50 gallon gas” leaves you guessing about the actual unit and its warranty. A model number lets you look those up and see whether the other shop is offering the same equipment.
Then check what happens around it:
That last list isn't a shopping list for every house. The installer needs to explain which items your job needs and whether they're included.

A heater in a garage and one tucked into an attic aren't the same installation. Tell the shop about stairs, narrow doors and limited access. Photos help, but the installer may still need to visit before settling the price.
A change from a gas tank to gas tankless can involve changes to the gas supply, venting and electrical connection. Have the shop price those changes for your house rather than comparing the two heaters' retail prices. Our tank or tankless guide explains that decision.
Water heater replacement requires a permit in Reno, Sparks and unincorporated Washoe County. The Contractors Board says the contractor must obtain it and arrange the inspection. Ask whether the quoted price includes both the permit fee and that work.
Also ask what happens if the installer finds something that changes the job. For residential contracts covered by Nevada's rules, changes to the work or price must be agreed in writing. A phone conversation about “a little extra work” is worth putting into the agreement before proceeding.
When a quote doesn't mention an item, ask. Missing wording doesn't tell you whether it's included, excluded or still undecided. The plumbing quote checklist covers the rest of the agreement.